Judge Dunstan Mlambo. (Sarel van der Walt)
- The DA has described a judgment on the government’s use of transformation criteria when providing relief as a “step back for non-racialism”.
- The party intends to appeal.
- The court dismissed the DA’s bid to stop the minister of small business development to stop using BBBEE status, race, gender, age or disability when considering who gets Covid-19 aid.
The DA intends to appeal a Gauteng High Court judgment that directed the government to use transformation criteria when providing relief.
On Friday, a full Bench dismissed the DA’s bid to stop Small Business Development Minister Khumbudzo Ntshavheni from using BBBEE status, race, gender, age or disability when considering who gets Covid-19 aid.
The court dismissed the DA’s assertions that the government’s decision to use transformation criteria when determining who gets economic relief was illegal.
“In the reformulation of criteria to be employed in the distribution of funds under either the Debt Finance Scheme or the Business Growth Resilience Fund, the minister must take into account race, gender, youth and disability,” Judge President Dunstan Mlambo said.
The party announced on Monday that it would appeal.
“It is both morally and legally indefensible that racist criteria are used in the context of distributing disaster relief,” DA spokesperson on small business development Zakhele Mbhele said in a statement.
Non-racialism
He said the judgment was a “step back for non-racialism and intensifies the impulse for the lens of race being applied to everything”.
Although the court had ruled that the department’s criteria by which people were chosen to receive aid be set aside and declared unlawful because they were too vague, it agreed that empowerment criteria had to be considered.
“The outbreak of Covid-19 in South Africa has brought sharply into focus the fissures in our society caused by race, gender and other forms of egregious discrimination,” the judgment read.
Mlambo said the court could not ignore South Africa’s deep racial divide.
“If we need any persuasion about the importance of our past and the [deep-]seated racial divide in contemporary South Africa and how the need for scarce resources fall overwhelmingly on those who are poor and therefore black, look no further than on whom the brunt of the effect Covid-19 falls.”
Mbhele said they believed there was a strong case that would require “rational exemptions from BBBEE policy”.
The DA initially told the court that Covid-19 affected everyone and relief should be distributed in a “neutral manner”.
